4.22.2012

Tainted Accomplishments in Baseball

I don’t know about you but for a person who loved baseball for the statistical comparison of ballplayers, that part of it doesn’t do it for me anymore. A few days ago Alex Rodriguez reached a milestone for home-runs hit in his career. When I heard the names that were just above him, Mays, Aaron and Ruth (I don’t even want to mention Bonds) something just didn’t feel right. An accomplishment that would have been met with great fanfare now felt like the dud you occasionally get in a pack of fireworks.

I don’t know what the future holds but if blessed with good health chances are that A-Rod will surpass everyone on the list by the time his contract runs out in 2017. But to me, no matter how many home runs he hits, there will always be that bad taste in my mouth left by the steroid scandal. These new records will seem tainted because we will always wonder how many were legitimate. For me, my boyhood idols of Ruth, Aaron and Mays will never be toppled off of the pedestal of baseball greatness. The achievements of a Harmon Killebrew who did things with pure raw power will never be overshadowed by one who relied on the assistance of some chemical enhancement. Paul Richards, Manager of the Baltimore Orioles said that, “Killebrew can knock the ball out of any park, including Yellowstone.”

I would like to embrace the legitimacy of these new records but I just can’t. We will never know how great these new ballplayers actually were. We will always question if they achieved their feats with the help of a druggist and they have no one to blame but themselves. I also think that if any of these ballplayers from the steroid era are selected to enter the Hall of Fame I would like to see them put in a different section. Maybe they could establish a wing denoting that their feats were accomplished during this questionable time.

I guess there are some records that appear to still be legit such as the feat accomplished by White Sox pitcher, Philip Humber (who?). He pitched a perfect game (retired all 27 batters he faced) marking only the 21st time that a perfecto has been thrown in MLB history. The reason I said who after his name is that he is not a well known pitcher. This was only his 30th big league start which turned out to be also his first complete game and 12th win of his career.

I wonder, is it harder to throw a perfect game or get a hole in one in golf?

No comments: